After the fugly 1960 design and the “blah” 1961 and 1962 designs, I’m really looking forward to this year’s Heritage. Too bad the Ol’ Perfessor won’t be in it.
Sorry about the missing right side of the card; that’s partly miscut source material, partly scanner.
2011 was an unusual collecting year for me. There wasn’t any particular set that I loved busting wax for, but there was a lot to love scattered about the various Topps sets. Rather than pick out a particular release as my favorite of the year, I’m going to build a Frankenset out of my favorite elements of 2011 sets.
First off, the base set is itself a Frankencard… The front would use the design from Topps Stickers, except it would be standard size and non-sticky. The back would be from the regular Topps set, and the cardstock would be Heritage.
Also from Heritage would be the manager cards and some of that classic slightly-ridiculously-posed photography:
2011 Heritage Adam Wainwright: Thanks to CheckOutMyCards.com for the image
Packaging for my set would include a rack pack much like what was used for Attax, where you could see at least one of the cards in the pack. I like packs like these, they bring me back to the day where you could decide which of the racks to buy based on the glossy insert or the base cards you could see. As long as I’m talking about packaging, I’d also like to see some sort of packs which have a lower price point by removing the “lottery” inserts but keeping the more common inserts. The Dollar Store insert-less packs are a bit spartan, but I’d also like the chance to get inserts without having to worry about whether Peter Johnson-Packfeeler has removed anything of value.
Here are the inserts I’d include in the 2011 Frankenset:
Diamond Giveaway code cards: Yeah, yeah, the free cards aren’t really free. Sure, you can probably get many of them cheaper through other sources, but screw that. Diamond Giveaway is fun. I’ve enjoyed signing on every day to see what’s been offered for my cards, see what ridiculously one-sided offers I’ve gotten for my 1961 Chuck Stobbs, whether anyone’s accepted my offer for that 1972 Danny Frisella, and so on. I also like the idea of an exclusive card for the giveaway; Even though I traded the one die-cut I got, it was still a moment of mojo and, through a series of trades I got a lot from that one die-cut (more on that in a later post).
Lineage 2011 Rookies: Unlike a lot of the other throwback-y inserts in Lineage and other sets, I remember pulling these cards out of rack packs, and I still have every one I pulled. Well, OK, not the doubles, but you get the idea.
Bowman inserts and Bowman as an insert: Rather than Bowman as a distinct brand, I think Bowman should be an insert which focuses on prospects rather than rookie cards. Bowman as a set has too many uninteresting veteran cards and non-prospect minor leaguers. I do really like some of the Bowman inserts, such as Topps 100 (and if an insert set ever begged to be in Topps instead of Bowman…).
I bought this card from COMC.com, it just hasn't shipped yet...
Funny, it wasn’t until I inserted this image in my post that I realized how Oriole-centric this post is turning out. Just as well, I’ve had enough Mets cards lately.
By the way, Xavier Avery has one of the coolest names in the minors, and if you ever hear him mentioned on TV or radio, it’s fun to hear them carefully pause a beat between first and last name so they don’t end up slurring it into Xavieravier…y.
Lineage 3-D inserts: I’m the right age to remember Kellogg’s 3-D cards, but for some reason I didn’t have any as a kid. I guess it might be because I wasn’t allowed to get many of the “kids cereals”. Doesn’t matter, 3-D cards are awesome!
Lineage 1975 Mini inserts: Although I never saw a 1975 mini until well into my adulthood, the 1975 Topps set is one of my all-time favorites, and the first set I ever completed. That being said, I still haven’t decided what to do with this insert. I was initially a little disappointed that it was a parallel (for the most part) rather than a stand-alone insert, but since I’ve not really taken the Lineage base set to heart, I could almost look on that set as the parallel. I’ll probably collect the Mets, Orioles and my other “guys” and leave it at that. Still, this is a great insert.
Cheerleader Cards: Wait a minute, how did this get in here? Not that it wouldn’t make a great baseball insert (and I doubt many of your are complaining…)
Topps 60: Another nice insert set, I like the mix of current and legend players on a non-ugly background. I guess it’s a good thing that Topps 60 and Topps 100 weren’t in the same set.
Honorable mention:
Aloha, Mr. Hand!
If I had to pick one and only one set, the regular Topps set would be it. This was a design subtle in it’s appeal… I liked it well enough when I saw the sneak peek images online, liked it a little more when I opened packs, liked it even more when I started putting cards into binders and saw how nice they look together in a sheet. I didn’t go for a lot of the inserts, but on the whole it was a well-above-average effort from Topps.
Also, I had a lot of fun busting packs of Attax and Stickers, even though neither is the type of set I would normally buy (and I’m still not really collecting either one). My internal grew-up-in-the-70′s child enjoys packs where there’s nothing but base cards, and where the mojo comes from getting one of your favorite players.
I don’t know about the rest of the country, but packs of Minor League Heritage are an elusive prey in my area. Fortunately, I didn’t have much interest in it from the start. I’ve bought minor league sets in the pasts, but even a Heritage price point is a bit steep for a set where many of the players won’t even get a cup of coffee. I also might’ve been more interested if they started this in a year with another design (1962 is very “blah”) and if it weren’t just another piece of the Bryce Harper hype machine. The kid’s only made it to AA and I’m already tired of him.
Getting back to the wax… I got this pack during a visit to my friendly neighborhood comic store (I’m a multi-media nerd), and paid $4.75 for the pack. I don’t know what these normally sell for, but based on what this particular store usually charges for cards, I have no doubts that I overpaid for it. Maybe I’ll get some mojo to make up for it… or at least a shortprint I can ship off to COMC. Are there short prints in this set? I don’t even know that much about it.
And away we go…
Adam Bailey, Lexington Legends
Ryan Jackson, Springfield Cardinals
Joe Kelly, Palm Beach Cardinals. Good pack for a Cardinals fan.
Simon Castro, Tucson Padres. You know, I think I might like the Tucson Padres uniforms better than the San Diego Padres uniforms. That can’t be good.
Gary Sanchez, Charleston Riverdogs
Juan Oramas, Lake Elsinore Storm
Carlos Perez, Rome Braves.
Jimmy Nelson, Wisconsin Timber Rattlers
Brett Lawrie, Las Vegas 51’s. Hey, I know that dude! I saw him play with Toronto against the O’s. I kinda like the Star Trek font on the 51’s uniform.
Wow. No inserts, no parallels, no short prints, no Mets or Orioles prospects, not even a guy I’ve seen play in one of the 10-15 minor league games I go to each year. I hope the comic store appreciates my $4.75, because I certainly didn’t get my money’s worth out of that puppy (other than giving me something to write about).
