Dr. Toppslove (Or: How I Learned To Stop Worrying And Love Archives)

When Topps released preview images of 2015 Archives, one image showed Vinny Castilla in the 1976 design (a personal favorite), and the bottom of the card said “COLORADO ROCKIES”… Not just “ROCKIES” like the 1976 cards would’ve had if the Rockies had been a baseball team in 1976.

“Oh, fer Pete’s sake!” I exclaimed (or something to that effect). “Can’t they get anything right?”

After this transgression had time to settle in my brain, I came to the conclusion that Topps can’t possibly be THAT incompetent, there must be some reason (legal or otherwise) why they don’t want to make Archives be exactly like the originals.  With that in mind, and with several of my favorite sets being featured, I decided that when the time came when Archives hits the shelves, I would just relax, not worry about the inaccuracies, wrong fonts and wrong colors and just go with it.

I tried to embrace these ideals yesterday when I found hanger-y value packs at a local Target.
2015 Topps Archives Value wrapper
I bought two, took them out to my car (while the theft prevention devices beeped at me because the cashier didn’t properly swipe the packs) and opened the first one while intending to save the other for later.

The first card was of George Springer…
2015 Topps Archives George Springer
…and I reacted with a small amount of delight because I like that photo and it works well with the 1976 design. Not only is it a slightly ridiculous fake batting pose, but if you look at the background, he’s not even on the field. It looks like he might be in the upper deck of whatever Spring Training complex he’s at.

“Not bad”, I thought, “Not at all bad”.

And you know what?  The card says “ASTROS”, not “HOUSTON ASTROS”.  This is one of the more notable differences I remember between preview images and the actual production.

The 1983 design (another favorite) also turned out pretty well, even if the fonts and some of the colors aren’t right. Again, not going to nitpick, just enjoy it. I know Fuji would enjoy this card of Kurt Suzuki.
2015 Topps Archives Kurt Suzuki

I’ve always been on the fence about the 1957 design; when it works, it works really well, but when it doesn’t work it ends up being a mess. I got this Robin Roberts card that has a nice 1950’s photo, and the text is largely legible, so this falls into the “it works!” category.
2015 Topps Archives Robin Roberts
Yes, the bottom of the card should say “PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES” instead of “PHILLIES”, but the photo outranks the nitpick.

Something I noticed;  Topps didn’t add their logo to the front of the 1957 cards.  I don’t know why they get a waiver while 1976 doesn’t (not that I care… Going with the flow, going with the flow…)

Then the pack started throwing Mets at me…
2015 Topps Archives Daniel Murphy

…and more Mets…
2015 Topps Archives Juan Lagares

…and still more Mets…
2015 Topps Archives Jacob deGrom

…And my favorite current Oriole…
2015 Topps Archives JJ Hardy

And it seemed like Topps was gunning for me.

I think it was around this time that I decided to go ahead and open both packs, “later” be damned.

I’m sure my different attitude helps, but there’s something about this year’s Archives that just strikes a chord with me… and not just all the players I like. I think part of it is the more-interesting-than-usual photos used, but that might be more indicative of something else going on here – I think Topps may have actually –


— put a small amount of EFFORT into this one!

Say it ain’t so, Joe! Say it ain’t so!

Sadly, I didn’t get a “1968 Game” insert. I also didn’t get a Will Ferrell insert, which I don’t care much about because Ferrell isn’t my sense of humor (and I’m sure I caused spit-takes the world over with that statement).

I did get this nice-looking silver Jose Altuve parallel #’ed to 199.
2015 Topps Archives Jose Altuve silver parallel
It looks grey in the scan, but it’s silver… Sort of. The same kind of “silver” that was used for parallels in Topps Total, for the handful of people who know what I’m talking about.

I also got a few of these All-Star Rookies in the 1990 style:
2015 Topps Archives Trevor May
I think they did a slightly better job on these than they did when 1990 Topps got “Archived” a few years ago.  Or maybe I’ve just successfully blocked those out of my memory.

This card made me say something stupid:
2015 Topps Archives Felix Hernandez
My immediate reaction was “Those aren’t the right colors for a 1976 Mariners card!” until I realized the stupidity of that thought (the M’s started in 1977).

I kinda liked this Lucroy card:
2015 Topps Archives Jonathan Lucroy

…And this Harmon Killebrew card, although I thought it would’ve been cool if they’d featured Killer during his career-ending stop with the Royals… but I would’ve been one of the few people who would’ve liked that.
2015 Topps Archives Harmon Killebrew

According to the back of his card, Killebrew’s career ended after 1967. That will come as news to a lot of people.
2015 Topps Archives Killebrew detail
Have they done this type of thing before in Archives? I don’t really look at the backs of these cards very much.

So those are the highlights of my two packs.

Something I rarely say: I’m going to buy more Archives.

Something I’ve never said before: I think I might buy a blaster of Archives.

For those of you who were  hoping that I’d trash Archives, I will say that the wrapper is tremendously boring. All that artwork sitting around in the Topps offices, and you go with a boring boilerplate 1980’s design? Whatever.


11 thoughts on “Dr. Toppslove (Or: How I Learned To Stop Worrying And Love Archives)

  1. I think it just goes to show you how subjective collecting is. You started out with a postitive attitude and found things to like. I’m a full bleed guy so the 1957’s appeal to me the most. I don’t know if I ever put Harmon Killebrew on a list of players to collect but he’s never a bad choice. Look forward to seeing more.

  2. You got some really good cards. I’m a big fan of the ’57 design so I might try to find some of those. I’d like to see some more Orioles on those.

  3. I think the ’76s turned out great. The other designs are about average to me. I’ll probably be pickup up a pack or two of Archives to check them out for myself. Nice pull on the Altuve!

  4. Bummer to hear their truncating career stats again this year. They started doing it last year. I hate it. Love to see a long tiny-text list of stats on the back of a retired great’s card.

  5. I don’t really see anything there that’s different from past years of Archives. I’ll pick up a couple of packs whenever it shows up around here. Pretty sure it won’t win me over.

  6. FYI, for trademark reasons “Colorado Rockies” and “Washington Nationals” will always be likely spelled out even when other team names are not.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.