Recently in my 1970s: A-Z series I’ve been making note of those players who appeared in all five Hostess sets of the 1970s. In the comments of the most recent post, San Jose Fuji wondered how many players are represented in all five sets.
“Good question”, I thought… and here we are.
There are 33 players who are featured in all five Hostess sets.
Thanks for reading, I’ll be back with another post soon!
Oh, right, like I would let an opportunity like this to go by without my over-analyzing what I found by querying my card database. As it turns out, this also gives me an opportunity to show off three Hostess cards I got at the Water Buffalo Lodge show… how fortuitous!
…Cards like this 1975 Hostess Steve Garvey.
…make sure you’re sitting down…
STEVE GARVEY HAS ONLY FOUR HOSTESS CARDS!!!!!
Some people are outraged that Garvey isn’t in the HOF, but it’s not the only slight of his career. Apparently starting the 1977 All-Star Game, winning a Gold Glove and driving in 115 runs was not sufficient to get Mr. Garvey into the 1978 Hostess set. Go figure.
Steve Garvey is not alone. Some other players who surprised me by not appearing in all five Hostess sets include Steve Carlton (missing from 1976), Don Sutton (1976), Carlton Fisk (1978), Rollie Fingers (1979) and Carl Yastrzemski (1978 & 1979).
Before I go any further, let’s take a quick break to show off another Hostess acquisition and then take a step back to look at the big picture.
This is the first of three Hostess cards for Rich “Goose” Gossage (1976, 1977, 1979)
There are 5 Hostess sets – 1975 to 1979 – with 150 cards each. That gives us a total of 750 cards. According to my findings, there are 332 different players featured in at least one Hostess set, which would average a little over 2.25 cards per player.
As I mentioned, there are 33 players who appear in all five sets: Bill Madlock, Bobby Murcer, Buddy Bell, Cesar Cedeño, Dave Concepción, Dave Kingman, Dave Lopes, Dave Winfield, Gary Matthews, Gaylord Perry, Gene Tenace, Graig Nettles, Greg Luzinski, Hal McRae, Jim Palmer, Jim Sundberg, Joe Morgan, Johnny Bench, Mike Hargrove, Mike Schmidt, Nolan Ryan, Pete Rose, Phil Niekro, Reggie Jackson, Rick Reuschel, Robin Yount, Rod Carew, Ron Cey, Ted Simmons, Thurman Munson, Toby Harrah, Tom Seaver, Willie Stargell.
UPDATE: There are *34* players who are in all five sets… I missed Bobby Grich because one of his Hostess cards was listed as “Bob Grich” in my database, so it didn’t sum up right. Thanks to Dime Boxes Nick for catching that!
Robin Yount is a fairly surprising member of this list, as his 1975 Hostess card came out the same season as his official rookie card. “Rookie year” cards don’t often show up in Hostess… for example, George Brett is also well-known for his 1975 rookie card, but didn’t show up in 1975 Hostess (and unlike Yount he got some 1974 Rookie of the Year votes). Brett appeared in every Hostess set from 1976 to 1979.
Even more surprising on the list of Five-Timers are Mike Hargrove (who was, at least, the 1974 AL ROY) and Rick Reuschel… (FYI, this Reuschel is not one of my new cards)
As you might think, there are more players with four cards than there are with five. I won’t list them all, but there are 42 of them. Some of the somewhat surprising players who did appear in 4 cards include Freddie Patek, John Candelaria, John Mayberry, Jorge Orta and Willie Montañez.
…and Larry Hisle. This well-loved example is the last of my new Hostess acquisitions.
Breaking it down the rest of the way, there are also 42 players with 3 cards, 76 with 2 cards and 139 with 1 card.
Part of why there might be a weird discrepancy of who gets in the sets and who does not is because Hostess tried to keep each team equally represented, more or less. Generally speaking there are 5 or 6 cards per team in any given Hostess set, so that might be why 1978 has no Garvey but does have Oakland’s Earl Williams and his 38 RBI.
One thing I discovered, and which is something that isn’t all that surprising, is that there are fewer cards of the Expos and Blue Jays than there are of the other teams. This makes sense since Hostess snack cakes weren’t sold in Canada. Yes, the Blue Jays were an expansion team in 1977 and didn’t have much in the way of good players, but they still had about half as many cards as their partners in expansion, the Seattle Mariners.
I’m sure if I put my mind to it I could slice ‘n dice the checklists in a number of other ways, but I think this is enough for now.
Dude. You are a rock star! Thank you for researching this. I think I’m going to try and track down all five Hostess cards for these players: Pete Rose, Rod Carew, and Thurman Munson. Maybe more after I get these three out of the way.
I would’ve never sought out such information myself, but it is kind of interesting to see who’s in all five sets, and who isn’t.
I try to take the approach of “I think it’s interesting, someone else will”. If I’m wrong… well, it’s not like I charge a fee or anything. :-)
I can’t believe Yaz isn’t in all five Hostess sets. That seems like a tragedy.
Isn’t Bobby Grich in all five sets? I seem to remember picking up all five of his Hostess cards at a single table at a card show a few years ago. I’ll have to consult my binders on that one.
You are right, Grich *is* in all five. I’ll have to look at my card database and see where it went wrong. Maybe one was listed as Bobby instead of Bob and got missed by the queries. My data integrity is not what I would like it to be
It is what I suspected… Four cards listed as “Bobby Grich”, one listed as “Bob Grich”. I tried to look for this type of thing up front, but I missed this one
I compiled this very same list awhile ago, but I don’t think I ever mentioned it on the blog. I don’t have access to it to contrast and compare as my dead old computer ate it and I don’t feel like retrieving it.
When I was writing the post, I wondered if you or anyone else had done it… but by that point I decided I’d gone too far to stop.