While others have been at the National, buying stuff on eBay or busting wax, I’ve been at home quietly reorganizing all of my cards from 1991. I started out with somewhere around 3500 1991 cards in my collection, I’m down to 2000, still working it and have been experimenting with a slightly different way of organizing my cards from a particular year… but that’s a story for another day.
While going through my cards and placing them into a pair of binders I’ve found a couple of “doppelgangers” I hadn’t been aware of.
It’s been a minute since I’ve written about Doppelgangers. That’s my term for two cards from different companies (or at least different sets) which depict the same moment, more or less.
This is my favorite example, featuring Geronimo Pena and Brett Butler, comes from 1994 Topps and 1994 Upper Deck Collector’s Choice:
Pretty much all of the Doppelgangers I’ve found so far have been from the early 1990s, so it’s no surprise that I found two more within 1991 sets.
The first one I discovered was this pair of Jeff Reardon cards from 1991 Topps and the back of a 1991 Upper Deck card:
Feel free to make your own guess as to which photo was taken first.
The second one I found shows Walt Weiss turning two (or attempting to) while Cleveland’s Joel Skinner slides into second.
Now these aren’t definitively the same moment, but so much is the same including the dirt stains on Weiss’ knee, so I’m pretty confident they are.
Since there are two different companies involved in sharing this moment, I feel pretty confident that the game played was from the year prior (1990). Cleveland didn’t visit Oakland a lot at the time and Joel Skinner played in only 49 games that year, so it wasn’t hard to determine that the game was from July 18th, 1990, Skinner’s only game in Oakland.
According to the boxscore on Baseball Reference, Skinner reached base twice that game… but the first time on base there wasn’t a play at second involving Skinner.
In the top of the 5th, Carlos Baerga lead off the inning with a single off of A’s pitcher Dave Stewart. Skinner followed with a walk, and then Jerry Browne grounded into a 4-6-3 double play, moving Baerga to 3rd (where he’d be stranded by by a Dion James popout). Seems like that’s our play.